Ahmad Awais

NAVIGATE


SHARE


New WordPress Plugin Repo Surprised Me!

Ahmad AwaisAhmad Awais

I am a WordPress plugin developer. While I have written many plugins for WordPress and shared them on GitHub, I also host 12 plugins on the WordPress.org/PluginsΒ repository β€” with more thanΒ 400kΒ total downloads.

A few days ago the new WordPress plugin repo went live, and I along with many other developers got surprised by that. I was very public with the feedback, I wrote about it on the Facebook’s Advanced WordPress group, wrote a post about it on WPLift, and in the form of comments on Make blog post.

But I feel like the feedback was either ignored, or the decision to make this new repo live was rushed with a few resources at hand, which could have addressed the feedback.

I Want To Like It!#

Don’t get me wrong. I want to really like the newΒ repo. The screenshots slider, the cleanΒ and minimal design part of which functions very well, is more than welcomed.

Maybe, we can have the description, screenshots, videos and all that on one page and then have other stuff like the changelog, FAQs, etc. in the form of tabs. Who knows!?

Sadly, there are issues, which we all knew about, from the beta. Those issues, are still there in the live version.

The Confusion#

With due respect (to the meta team), there seems to be a confusion here of some sorts. On one side, developers are being considered not the right audience for several categories of our feedback, and then there is this expectation of having the feedback reported back asΒ Trac tickets. Not sure how regular users would do that.

And WordPress doesn’t seem to have a good way of collecting feedback from 80% of its user’s base that we are calling users . Surveys only report back a fraction of that user base.

Morten’s suggestions about telemetry are on point here. This is the right time to start thinking in the form of data. Collecting data is important for each and every one of us. ItΒ could help devs, decision makers, writers, and in general be our guide for a better future of WordPress.

Honestly, I have nothing but appreciation for all the work done by the meta team to help the WordPress community. It’s commendable. That’s not what my complaint is about. It’s about how things got handled and what can we do about it, the next time.

What I Think!#

The facts below do not make a lot of sense to me:

  1. Developers’ feedback is sometimes considered less important (as mentioned here the 80/20 rule being used or misused to quote Matt Mullenweg).
  2. No WP Telemetry, no A/B testing is being done to get feedback from the ever growing WordPress userbase.
  3. Trac should not be the ONLY place where tickets get qualified as feedback. Comments on the Make blog posts are valuable as well. And there were many.
  4. If there were limited resources, then meta team could have waited a bit to weed out the feedback against the Read More links and one-page design.
  5. Making the beta live by not considering all those comments devs left β€” makes me think that our feedback was just right off ignored. My initial perception was that the meta team would eventually write a post about what is being considered for the next iteration (the one which was supposed to go live)
  6. IMHO, there was no announcement. When the new plugins repo went live β€” it was a surprise to many of us. I believe I have an excellent handle on WordPress news β€”what’s happening and when is it happening β€” that kind of stuff. But I along with many others got what I would call a surprise when I saw the new repo was live. (I could be wrong, I am only human)
  7. Complaints of pixelated images are the by-product of this surprise (see #6) as I think many devs were not using the Retina version of the banner image that is β€” banner-1544x500.pngΒ and hence they were not prepared for the new repo.
  8. Yes, it’s a good thing that the new backend is something meta team is comfortable with. And that there will be new iterations, more often. But that doesn’t justify why the UI looks the way it does now, why the feedback was not considered, and why the repo went live without a notification of what’s going to happen.

Not a Pleasant Surprise#

For me it was not a pleasant surprise, I had to stop everything I was doing and take a look at my plugins, to check if I need to update my free plugins since the new layout was live. Had I knew that the design was going live on a particular date, I would have prepped for it.

IMHO#

I feel like my feedback was similar to many many other developers like John Brown, Kevin, Matt, Joe, etc. Along with them, (if I be as bold to say that)Β I feel that my feedback didn’t change a thing.

I am looking forward to the new iterations ahead.

P.S. If there was an announcement before the new layout was live, then it’s my bad, I completely missed it, though, IMHO there was no announcement even after the design went live for a good 30 minutes or so. Since, I searched for one on the Make blog, before sharing the news inside AWP group. It almost felt like someone would have accidently pushed the new repo into live mode.Β 

UPDATES!#

Helping businesses understand developers. Head of Developer Relations RapidAPI πŸ“Ÿ Edutainer at Node.js CLI Automation and VSCode.pro 🎩 Award-winning Open Source Engineer & Dev Advocate 🦊 Google Developers Expert Web DevRel πŸš€ Mars Ingenuity Helicopter code contributor πŸ† 8th GitHub Stars Award recipient 🌳 Node.js foundation Community Committee Outreach Lead, Member Linux Foundation, OpenAPI, DigitalOcean Navigator ✌️ Author of various open-source dev-tools and software libraries used by millions of developers worldwide ⓦ WordPress Core Developer πŸ“£ TEDx Speaker with 100+ talks πŸ™Œ Leading developers and publishing technical content for over a decade πŸ’œ Loves his wife (Maedah) ❯ Learn more β†’

Say πŸ‘‹ on Twitter @MrAhmadAwais | Subscribe to the Developers Takeaway!

πŸ“¨

Developers Takeaway

Takeaway my professional opinion on open-source, developer relations, growing your business with family, and everything in between! Delivered to your inbox a couple of times every year. I'm even funny at times. I hate spam β€” pinky-promise!

πŸ‘¨β€πŸ’»πŸ‘©β€πŸ’» 118,947 Developers Already Subscribed
Comments 14
  • Ashley
    Posted on

    Ashley Ashley

    Reply Author

    Well said, Ahmad! I completely agree.


    • AhmadAwais
      Posted on

      AhmadAwais AhmadAwais

      Reply Author

      I’m glad to not be alone in thinking like this.


  • M Asif Rahman
    Posted on

    M Asif Rahman M Asif Rahman

    Reply Author

    You spoke most of our mind, Ahmed. Months after month we discussed about it. There were many slack meeting, but ultimately it was almost the same design we had seen hundreds of days ago. Sad!


    • Ahmad Awais
      Posted on

      Ahmad Awais Ahmad Awais

      Reply Author

      I hope it will be better. The feedback this time has enormously been in favour of tabs and against the read more links. The last reviews right on the front page are a bad call too, IMO.


  • Goran
    Posted on

    Goran Goran

    Reply Author

    Well for a couple of months i believe, there was a beta link standing there, then alot of people on slack were telling against one pager and in favor of tabs. But in the end it didn’t change a thing and new design went live without some kind of announcement. I have 4 plugins, 8000 active installs, had to jump to fix issues with images. Also i have 50% less visits to one of my premium plugins as a link is at the bottom, hidden with a read more. IMO they should have done A/B when the beta was live, that should have been easy but they didnt.


    • AhmadAwais
      Posted on

      AhmadAwais AhmadAwais

      Reply Author

      Just what I said, an unpleasant surprise. I wish it could have been dealt better.


  • Muti
    Posted on

    Muti Muti

    Reply Author

    Well, i am not happy, why would anyone develop for WordPress now as they already know that they cannot get any rating without any personal efforts or spending money on adwords to advertise their plugin. How would people have a notion that they have developed a plugin which is comparetavily better or has far better user experience.

    If nobody knows about their plugin, how anyone will use it. All the giants will have a bash by getting ratings and active installs based upon their previous rating and active installs at first


  • Igor
    Posted on

    Igor Igor

    Reply Author

    I have a feeling that many things are being ignored by the WordPress “heads” nowadays. It feels like they’ll just do what they had in mind without ever accepting any feedback from others.

    This is somehow similar to the WordCamp situation where they won’t allow country-wide WordCamps for smaller countries (https://www.roytanck.com/2017/03/30/wordcamp-netherlands-just-got-cancelled-and-thats-a-mistake/).

    I still believe WordPress community is a great one and we can change a part of the internet (world) with WordPress. But, I really don’t like how some parts of this community is treated.

    That’s maybe normal when you are part of such a big community, I am not sure.


  • Jim True
    Posted on

    Jim True Jim True

    Reply Author

    Thanks for this. I feel like I contributed feedback for several months and it has largely been ignored or has been shot down in favor of “design over function”. Where were the User Personas that should have been gathered if this was supposed to improve usability?


    • Luke Cavanagh
      Posted on

      Luke Cavanagh Luke Cavanagh

      Reply Author

      +100 for data-driven user personas for WP end-users.


  • Luke Cavanagh
    Posted on

    Luke Cavanagh Luke Cavanagh

    Reply Author

    The key point is WordPress strives to never break backwards compatibility, so that should apply to core and meta.


  • Mani Khan
    Posted on

    Mani Khan Mani Khan

    Reply Author

    Salam
    just correct this post slug :)
    *Repository


  • John Dee
    Posted on

    John Dee John Dee

    Reply Author

    The repo is a nightname and Automattic has utterly failed the ecosystem. They are only concerned with corporate capture, not making the platform better. There is no competition for the repo, whereas there is competition in page builders. Hence we get Gutenberg jammed down our throat, and the repo is still using SVN. I call for a fork of the system away from Automattic.